Miley Cyrus’ bid for dismissal in Bruno Mars lawsuit might be denied by judge

Miley Cyrus may have to face music, as it seems that a federal judge “is likely” to refuse to try to reject a lawsuit for violating the copyright raised on the Grammy award -winning song, who accused the singer and songwriter of copying the Bruno Mars song “when I was a man.

During a court hearing in Los Angeles on Monday, Judge Diane de Gerrson has repeatedly indicated that the prosecutor, rhythmic music investments, had a legal status to move forward in the case, according to Rolling Stone.

In September, Tempo Music Investments filed a lawsuit against Cyrus and many of the participating defendants, claiming that “flowers” endured “amazing similarities” to “when I was your leg”, including “many compatible, compatible and lyrical elements.”

Miley Cyrus accused of copying Bruno Mars in a lawsuit for the song “Al -Zuhur”

Cyrus’ lawyers denied these claims and made a proposal to reject the lawsuit, on the pretext that the TEMPO investments, which only had a breaking share of the song of Mars that the company bought from one of its senior participants, Philip Lawrence, around 2020, did not have the situation on “flowers”.

It seems that a “possible” federal judge refuses to request Miley Cyrus to dismiss him after being prosecuting his copy of one of Bruno March’s songs. (Getty Images / Getty Images)

However, Rolling Stone reported that Pregerson seems to be consistent several times with the arguments by Tempo Music Investments, Alex Weingarten.

“There is a deep political issue before the court. Adopting the rule he urged [Cyrus] The entire music industry will turn, and in fact the technology industry, too, will turn its ear. policy is behind the law of copyright for people to freedom [sell] Winjarin said in court, for the entire port.

Pressson seemed to refer to the support of logic, noting “or if someone dies and someone gains attention through a property. Suddenly they lose the right to enforce it.”

According to Rolling Stone, Pregerson had earlier wondered what anyone could motivate a fracture share in the song “Knowing that they can never impose it” unless they get permission from all the authors participating.

“Specifically, your honor,” he answered Weingarten. “It is not glorified. If it does not include the right to enforce this right, then the right is meaningless. You cannot have a rule where if the owner of the copyright dies, then his property is unable to implement those copyrights.”

Pressson immediately did not issue a ruling regarding the dismissal proposal. However, he said he would issue a written decision in the coming weeks and months.

A lawsuit claimed that Miley Cyrus’ Grammy Grammy Grammy “Flowers” toured “Amazing similarities” of Bruno Mars’s song “when I was your man.” (Getty Images / Getty Images)

According to Reno, Nevada, Ten Country@97.3, citing the court’s version, and the judge stated that he was “likely to refuse to reject the case” on the basis that he believes that the plaintiffs have “merit”.

Cyrus won its first collection of Grammy’s victory in the year’s record and the best single pop performance for “Al -Zuhoor” at the sixty -sixth annual awards exhibition in February 2024.

“Wrecking Ball” Hitmaker performed the song live during the ceremony, and “Flowers” also received the best honor for international songs at the BRIS 2024 Awards.

Ed Sheeran faces “Thinking out loud

“Flowers” became a feeling overnight, as it appeared first on the Billboard Hot 100 chart and broke the record to become the fastest song up to one billion streams on Spotify.

“Build the rule that he urged [Cyrus] The entire music industry will turn, and in fact the technology industry, too, will turn its ear. “

– Tempo Alex Wexarten

A lawsuit at Tempo Music Investments said, “Any lover of Bruno Mars” when I was your man “knows that Miley Cyrus flowers” did not achieve all this success on its own. “

“Flowers” repeat many elements of melody, compatibility and lyrical from “when you were your leg”, including the design of the stadium to bend and the verse sequence, the connected Line-Line, certain tapes of the choir, some theatrical theatrical elements, lyric elements, and specific progress, “

“It cannot be denied, based on the mix and the number of similarities between the two recording, that” flowers “will not exist without” when you were your leg. “

A comparison was included along with the lyrics of the two songs in the court documents. (Foxbusiness)

“The opening audio line of the” flowers “choir begins and ends on the same ropes as the opening audio line in a verse” when I was your leg. “

The documents included a display alongside the words “When I was your leg” and “flowers” to show the alleged similarities.

The lyrics of the songs displayed in “When I were your leg” include “I must bring flowers for you” and “stick to your hand”, “He should give you all my hours” and “take you to every party because everything you want to do is dance.”

Meanwhile, the words of “flowers” include “I can buy flowers myself”, “I can hold my hand”, “Talk to myself for hours” and “I can take myself dance.”

Mars was not mentioned as a claimant.

Along with Cyrus, the adult “flowers” Gregory Hain and Michael Pollack were inserted into the alleged “exploitation” lawsuit. Several defendants were named, along with Sony Music Publishing and Apple, as well as court documents.

Mars wrote, “When I was your man,” written by the singer, Philip Lawrence, Arie Levin and Andrew White.

Bruno Mars was not named as a claimant. (Theo Wargo / Getty Emociz for the Academy of Registration / Getty Pictures)

After its release in December 2012, “when I was your leg” became a huge blow. More than 16 weeks after Billboard Hot 100, Mars’s song rose to first in April 2013.

Click here to read more on Fox Business

MARS also received Grammy’s best nomination for the best pop performance for Tune in December 2013, and in 2014, the song won the “Most Song Song” awards at pop music awards hosted by the American Association for Authors, Authors and publishers (ASCAP).

In May 2021, “When I was your man” got the eleventh platinum certificate.

Miley Cyrus made a proposal to get around in November. (Vijat Mohindra/Peacock/NBCU Photo Bank via Getty Images/Getty Images)

Dan Stone, partner in the Greenberg Group Group Glosker, told Fox Business that copyright cases are “very common” but rarely include celebrities. He said that Cyrus was named as a defendant because it was one of the big “flowers”.

Stone also managed to face whether Cyrus would face difficulties in proving that she and her participation in her book did not fall “when I was your man.”

“The plaintiff will have to prove that” flowers “violated the copyright of the musical composition,” when you were your leg. “If the parties do not settle before the trial, it is possible that the trial will include a testimony on how Miley and its writers wrote in” flowers “.

“Both sides will usually present the certificate of experts from music scientists trained about whether the” flowers “and” when I were your leg “are very similar, including comparing paper music and songs of songs.

Get Fox Business on the Go by clicking here

Stephanie Jiang-Bonnon and Hessi Wright contributed to Fox Business to this report.